How to Get More Comments on YouTube Videos and Shorts

Your video has a few hundred views, people watched most of it, a few even liked it, and the comment section is still empty. Or there is one comment, and it is spam. It feels like talking to a room where everyone nods and nobody says anything.
Most viewers never comment on anything, so an empty section is normal for a small channel. It does not mean the video failed. But comments can be encouraged. People comment when they have something specific to say, when they think someone will read it, and when the first few comments show that a conversation is going on.
This guide covers how comments work on YouTube right now, what to check when comments seem to be missing, and eight methods that get more people talking under your videos and Shorts, each with an example.
How YouTube Comments Work
Comments appear below a regular video and in a panel that opens from the comment icon on a Short. Viewers can sort them two ways. Newest first shows them by date. Top comments is YouTube's ranked view: its help center says it shows what viewers are likely to value and interact with, based on signals such as the comment text, the channel name, the avatar, the viewer and the video. That ranked view is what most people see first.
As a creator, you have a few tools that viewers do not. You can pin one comment, your own or a viewer's, to the top. You can heart a comment, which shows your avatar with a small red heart under it. And you can reply. YouTube says that when you heart, pin or reply, the commenter may get a notification, which is often what brings them back.
One thing to be clear about: YouTube's page on how recommendations work lists signals such as viewing behaviour, likes, dislikes, subscriptions and feedback from surveys. It does not name comments. So treat comments as a way to build a community around your channel, not as a lever for recommendations.
First, Check Whether Comments Are Being Held or Hidden
Sometimes the comments exist, but nobody can see them. Before changing how you make videos, open YouTube Studio and check these:
- Held for review. YouTube holds potentially inappropriate comments for review by default. Held comments, including ones labelled "Likely spam", sit in the Held for review tab in Studio's Comments page until you approve them, for up to 60 days. Real comments with links or unusual wording often land there.
- Moderation level. In comment settings you can choose None, Basic, Strict or Hold all. If someone set the channel to Hold all, every comment waits for approval.
- Comments turned off or limited. Comments can be on, paused or off for each video, or limited to subscribers or members.
- Made for kids. Comments are turned off on videos set as made for kids. If your video was marked that way, nobody can comment.
- Blocked words and links. Comments containing words or links on your blocked list are held.
- Spam detection. YouTube's automatic systems scan comments. Its help page lists posting many comments in a short time, repeating the same comment and sharing links as signs of spam. Comments flagged as potentially inappropriate, spam or impersonation may also not appear in Top comments.
If you find real comments waiting in the Held tab, approve them and reply. A viewer whose comment sat unseen for a week is unlikely to comment again unless you show that you read it.
1. Ask One Specific Question in the Video
"Let me know what you think in the comments" rarely works, because it asks the viewer to invent a topic. A specific question with an easy answer does work, because the viewer already has the answer in their head.
What to do: pick one question that every viewer can answer from their own experience, ask it out loud at a natural point in the video, and repeat it as the first line of your pinned comment. YouTube explicitly allows asking viewers to leave a comment, so there is no need to hide it.
Example: a cooking channel making a weeknight pasta video asks, "What is the one ingredient you always add to tomato sauce?" Everyone who cooks has an answer, it takes three words to reply, and the answers are interesting to other viewers, so people read and reply to each other.
Good questions usually are:
- Personal: about the viewer's own experience, setup or opinion.
- Short to answer: one word or one sentence is enough.
- Open to different answers: there is no single correct reply, so people compare.
2. Pin a Comment That Starts the Conversation
The pinned comment is the first thing people see when they open the comments, so use it to start something rather than to repeat the video title. You can pin your own comment or a viewer's, and pinning a new one replaces the old. Pinning requires advanced features to be turned on for your channel. On mobile, viewers see the pinned comment once they open the comment section.
What to do: pin your question from the video, a correction or extra detail you left out, or a viewer's comment that asks something others will want answered. Change the pin after the first day if a better comment appears.
Example: a tech reviewer pins, "I didn't test battery life on 5G in this video. If you own this phone, how many hours do you get?" Owners answer with numbers, and people thinking of buying it read the thread.
3. Get the First Comments Under a New Video
An empty comment section is a weak invitation. A viewer is more likely to add a comment when a few people have already started talking, and the first hours after upload are when the most viewers see the video at once.
What to do:
- Be there after upload. Plan to be around for the first hour or two and reply to every comment as it arrives.
- Bring in the people who already care. Tell your existing audience about the new video in a channel post, a newsletter or a community you run, and ask them the same question as in the video.
- Answer held comments quickly. Check the Held for review tab after upload, so early comments do not sit hidden.
Some creators do not want a new video to sit with zero comments while they wait, and pay for the first few instead. If you go that way, the option closest to real discussion is comments from real people who watched the video. For example, you can buy YouTube comments from real people on RapidWorkers and read each one before you pay. Be clear about the rule, though: YouTube's fake engagement policy does not allow anything that artificially increases comments, so any paid comments are a risk you take on, and YouTube may remove them.
4. Reply and Heart in the First Hours
People comment more on channels where the creator answers. Because a reply or heart can send the commenter a notification, it also brings them back to the video, where they often read and reply to other comments.
What to do: reply with something that continues the conversation, not just "thanks!". Ask a follow-up question, add a detail, or disagree politely. Heart the comments you cannot reply to. In the YouTube Studio app, the comments section has filters such as Unresponded, so you can see who is still waiting for an answer.
Example: a viewer writes, "I tried this and my bread came out flat." Instead of "Sorry to hear that", the baker replies, "Did you use the same flour? Flat loaves are usually a sign the dough over-proofed. How long did you leave it?" Other viewers with the same problem join in, and the thread becomes useful.
5. Use Shorts Features Built for Replies
Shorts are watched quickly and swiped past, so comments there need an even lower barrier. YouTube gives Shorts two features that help directly:
- Q&A sticker. You add a question to the Short, and YouTube says viewers' responses become comments that are public and visible to other viewers. It turns answering into one tap and a few words.
- Reply to comments with a Short. You can answer a comment by making a new Short. The comment appears as a sticker in the video, and the reply shows up below the original comment, letting the commenter know.
What to do: on Shorts, ask the question on screen in the first seconds, not at the end when people have already swiped. Use the Q&A sticker for questions with short answers. When a comment asks something interesting, answer it with a Short, which shows viewers that commenting can get them a whole video.
Example: a fitness creator posts a 30-second Short of a stretching routine with a Q&A sticker: "Where do you feel tight after sitting all day?" The answers ("hips", "lower back") become comments, and the most common one becomes the next Short, replying to that comment.
6. Turn Comments Into Content
When viewers see their comments answered in a video, they learn that commenting is worth it. That habit carries over to every video you post.
What to do: mention good comments by name in your next video, answer common questions in a follow-up, and credit the viewer who suggested an idea. For videos with enough comments, YouTube Studio can generate a comment summary with AI, which shows how viewers responded and can help you spot questions that come up repeatedly.
Example: a gardening channel opens each video with, "Last week Maria asked why her tomato leaves curl. Here's the answer." Viewers start writing questions in the hope of being featured.
7. Leave Room for an Opinion
People comment when they have something to add. A video that says everything and leaves nothing open gets "great video" at best. A video with a clear position or a ranking invites viewers to agree, disagree or add what you missed.
What to do: give a clear opinion and say why. Use rankings, "my top 5" lists, comparisons and predictions, and say openly that you expect people to disagree. Keep it honest: deliberately wrong claims to provoke angry comments hurt trust, and the discussion they create is not one you want under your name.
Example: a board game channel ranks the ten best games for two players and ends with, "I left out one very popular game on purpose. Which one do you think it is, and was I wrong?" The comment section fills with guesses and alternative lists.
8. Continue the Conversation in Posts
Comments under one video end when people stop watching it. YouTube's Posts tab keeps the conversation going between uploads. YouTube says posts can give you more reach and engagement with your audience, and they support text, images, videos, playlists, polls and quizzes.
What to do: after a video with an active comment section, post a follow-up question or a poll on the same topic. Ask viewers what you should cover next, then make that video and say it came from their answers.
How to Get Top Comment on YouTube
Many people asking how to get comments on YouTube actually want their own comment to rise to the top under someone else's video. YouTube does not publish a formula, but its help page says Top comments shows what viewers are likely to value and interact with. In practice, that means:
- Comment early. Comments posted soon after upload are seen by more people while the video is new.
- Add something specific. A timestamp, a fact, a funny observation about a particular moment or a useful correction earns likes and replies. "First!" and "Nice video" do not.
- Keep it readable. One or two clear sentences beat a wall of text.
- Avoid links and self-promotion. Links are one of the spam signs YouTube lists, and comments flagged as spam may not appear in Top comments at all.
- Hope the creator notices. A heart or a pin from the creator puts your comment in front of everyone.
Common Mistakes That Get Comments Removed or Channels Limited
- Comment-for-comment and sub4sub deals. YouTube's fake engagement policy lists sub4sub schemes and does not allow anything that artificially increases views, likes, comments or other metrics.
- Rewarding comments. The spam policy covers offering rewards in exchange for engagement, and content that exists only to incentivize engagement is prohibited. If you run a giveaway, YouTube's contest policies make you solely responsible for it, and they forbid manipulating metrics to misrepresent genuine engagement.
- Bots and repetitive comments. High-volume, repetitive or deceptive comments are comment spam under YouTube's policy, and its systems scan for them.
- Posting your own links under other videos. It looks like spam to viewers and to YouTube's detection, and it rarely brings anyone to your channel.
- Forgetting the Held tab. Real comments can wait there for up to 60 days, unseen.
- Marking a video made for kids by mistake. Comments are turned off on those videos.
- Answering criticism defensively. Viewers read the thread. A calm, useful reply to criticism makes people more willing to comment, not less.
When Organic Growth Is Too Slow
Everything above works, but slowly, especially for a new channel with few viewers. A good question in the video only helps if enough people watch to answer it.
If you do not want to wait, RapidWorkers is one option. It is a microtask marketplace: you post a task, real people complete it, and you pay per completed action. For YouTube comments, you paste your video link and either give the exact comment text or a brief with the topic, tone, length and language, so each worker writes their own. You set the number of comments and the reward, and choose countries from more than 200. Workers watch the video, comment from their own YouTube accounts, and send the proof you ask for, such as a playback screenshot and a screenshot of the published comment with their username. You read each comment and pay only for the ones you approve.
Comment tasks start at $0.05, plus a 15% platform fee, so 100 comments at that reward cost $5.75 in total. The landing page gives example rewards of $0.05 to $0.07 for a short comment, $0.07 to $0.08 for two or three sentences, $0.08 to $0.10 for a comment that asks a question about something in the video, and $0.10 or more for detailed or custom comments. You only share the public link, never a password.
Keep the limits in mind. YouTube's moderation is outside anyone's control, so nobody can promise a comment stays up, and YouTube's fake engagement policy does not allow artificially increasing comments. Paid comments also cannot make a video worth discussing. If you still want them, keep the number small, ask for comments that respond to what is actually in the video, and keep replying yourself. You can see task examples on the page to buy YouTube comments.
Conclusion
Start by checking that comments are not stuck in the Held tab, turned off or blocked by a made-for-kids setting. Then make commenting easy and worth it:
- Ask one specific question that every viewer can answer, and repeat it in a pinned comment.
- Be around after upload, and reply with follow-up questions rather than "thanks".
- On Shorts, ask on screen early and use the Q&A sticker and replies with Shorts.
- Turn good comments into videos, so viewers see that commenting gets noticed.
- Take a clear position and leave room for viewers to add what you missed.
- Stay away from comment swaps, rewards and bots, which YouTube's policies prohibit.
Comments follow conversations people want to join. Give them a reason to speak, show that you are listening, and the section will start to fill.
Ready to Get Started?
Join thousands of workers and employers already using RapidWorkers to get tasks done fast.
- No subscription
- Cancel anytime
- 24/7 availability
- Dispute resolution


